Insight · Strategy

What a marketing audit should cover, and how to read the result

A marketing audit checklist from practice: the eight areas to review, how the work runs, what drives the cost and the red flags to watch for in a provider.

A brass magnifying glass on a leather notebook beside an old compass and reading glasses on an oak desk

A marketing audit is a written review of where your leads and sales actually come from, what each channel costs you and where money leaks on the way from the first click to the invoice. A good one fits on a few pages and ends with a short ranked list of changes, each with a name next to it and a date. A bad one is sixty slides of screenshots. This is the checklist we work from at Marketing MIX, in the order we use it, plus the signs that an "audit" is really a sales pitch.

What a marketing audit is for

People usually call us for an audit at one of four moments. Leads fell and nobody knows why. A new head of marketing started and wants a baseline. Next year's budget is on the table. Or the company is about to leave its agency. The groundwork is the same each time, only the question on top changes. After a drop you need dates and causes. A new hire needs a map of what is running. Budget season needs cost per lead by channel. Before an agency switch you need to find out which ad accounts and analytics tags the company owns, as opposed to the agency.

Whatever the reason for calling, the report has to answer the same thing in plain words. Which channels bring people who end up paying? Which ones bring visits and stop there? What breaks in between? The rest of the pages are there to back those answers up.

Website review: two fields

Your site and how to reach you. We send back what to fix first and a one-month plan, by email or text.

By sending, you agree that Marketing MIX uses these details to answer you. Privacy. The request is deleted automatically 180 days after it arrives.

The checklist: eight areas we review

We go through them in this order on client accounts. Measurement is first for a reason: if the numbers are wrong, so is every conclusion drawn from them.

AreaWhat we checkWhat we often find
1. MeasurementGA4 key events, call tracking, source fields in the CRM, consent setupForms counted twice, calls not counted at all
2. Lead pathEach form and messenger link, from the click to the inboxThe contact form still mails an old address nobody opens
3. Search (SEO)Queries and pages in Search Console, indexing, technical health, local listingsService pages missing from the index; blog posts ranking for the wrong intent
4. Paid adsAccount structure, search terms, conversion setup, landing pagesMoney going to broad terms that never convert
5. Social and contentWhat gets posted, and where it sends peopleSteady posting with no link to an offer or a form
6. WebsiteSpeed on a phone; how plainly the money pages state the offerThe main service page sits two clicks deep
7. CompetitorsWho ranks and advertises on your queries, and what they promiseA rival with a clearer offer at about the same price
8. CostsSpend and staff hours per channel, set against leads and salesA channel that is cheap per click and expensive per customer

If you only need the search side, our technical SEO audit checklist goes further into indexing and Core Web Vitals.

How the work runs, step by step

  1. Access. Read-only logins to GA4, Search Console, the ad accounts and the CRM, and a list of everyone who touches marketing. For a small or mid-size company collecting this takes a few days, most of it spent waiting for passwords.
  2. Measurement check. We send test leads through every form, tap every phone number and messenger link, and then look for each one in analytics and in the CRM with the correct source attached.
  3. A year of data. Leads and sales by channel and month. Seasonality shows up, and a slow December stops being blamed on the website.
  4. Channel reviews. Search, ads, social, email. Each one is judged against what it costs.
  5. Competitor and market scan. Who appears on your money queries and what they offer. When you are entering a new market, a separate market analysis does that job better.
  6. Written report. Findings first, then the ranked fixes: what to stop, what to repair this month, what to test next quarter.

How long it takes depends on the number of channels and on how much of the tracking works. One website with Google Ads and a CRM is a small job. Three sites, five ad accounts and leads coming in over WhatsApp is a much bigger one. Be careful with anyone who promises a fixed timeline before opening the accounts; an honest estimate comes after the first look at the data.

What drives the cost of an audit

We quote each audit for its scope. Five things move that number, at our studio and at most others:

  • how many channels and ad accounts are in scope;
  • how many websites, in how many languages;
  • the tracking (clean GA4 plus a CRM with source fields makes it quicker, a site with no analytics history makes it slower);
  • how deep the competitor part goes, from the top three rivals to a whole category;
  • whether the report ends at findings or comes with a plan, budgets and a calendar.

Cheap "audits" offered as lead magnets are mostly crawler exports: a score out of 100 and a few hundred warnings sorted by severity. Crawlers are useful on day one. What they cannot reach is the CRM, the margin on a job, or the reason a customer signed with a competitor last month.

Red flags when choosing who does it

Over the years prospects have sent us a lot of audits done by other firms. The weak ones look alike:

  • Every problem the audit finds sits in a channel the agency sells.
  • Nobody asked for access to your accounts, so all of it came from public tools.
  • Each recommendation is "more" (posts, budget, pages) and nothing is marked "stop".
  • Cost per lead and cost per customer appear nowhere.
  • The findings are a slide deck with no written explanation you could forward to a colleague.

So ask for the outline of a past report before you sign anything. Anyone who does this for a living will send one over with the client's name blacked out.

After the audit

An audit only pays off when somebody acts on it. Our usual sequence: thirty days of fixes on measurement and the lead path, a quarter for channel changes, then a fresh look at the numbers. Tracking fixes show the same day. Ads respond within a few weeks. Search is slow, two to four months before traffic moves and often longer in a crowded niche. When the audit says search is the main gap, our SEO promotion team can take the plan straight from the report.

We have been doing marketing for companies in Canada and Europe since 2012, and we still open every new engagement with this review.

FAQ

What does a marketing audit include?

Eight areas, from measurement and the lead path to competitors and what each channel costs. The result is a written list of fixes in order of expected effect.

How long does a marketing audit take?

It depends on the number of channels and sites, and on how broken the tracking is. You get a real timeline after the first look at the accounts.

Can I audit my marketing myself?

The basics, yes: leads by source, spend by channel, a test of every form. Where an outside specialist helps most is reading those numbers against competitors and your margins.

What is the difference between a marketing audit and an SEO audit?

An SEO audit is about search only: indexing, technical health, content, backlinks. A marketing audit covers all the channels and what each one costs, and search is one chapter of it.

↘Next move

READY TO BE FOUND BY HUMANS AND MACHINES?

First step

Website review and a one-month plan

Send your site address. We look at the site, your ads and your search presence and send back what to fix first and a one-month plan. Ads management is quoted after the review.

Or reach the studio directly
+1 613 867 7767Messengerinfo@mmix.biz